Neither route is better in general. A degree apprenticeship and a traditional degree can both end in the same qualification, so the real choice is between two ways of getting there: studying full time and borrowing to pay for it, or working for an employer, being paid, and studying alongside. The right answer depends on the career you are aiming at, how you learn best, and the grades you are on course for. That last part is where good school and sixth-form data helps, because the subjects and results you take at 16 to 18 keep both doors open.
SchoolwizeKeep Sixth-Form Options in ViewCompare sixth forms using official results, subject-level detail and local context as you consider which qualifications may keep both routes open.Visit
Key Takeaways
- A degree apprenticeship leads to a full bachelor’s or master’s degree, with tuition paid by the employer and government, while a university student pays fees of up to £9,790 a year in 2026/27.
- Apprentices work most of the week, usually about 80%, and study the rest, so the pace is closer to a full-time job than student life.
- Completion rates differ: about 55% for apprenticeships overall against about 89% for university degrees, according to the King’s College London Policy Institute.
- Some careers in healthcare, business and science require a degree, so check the entry route for your chosen job before you decide.
- Your A-level or GCSE subject results shape which options are open, so compare sixth forms subject by subject before you commit.
Table of Contents
- What the two routes actually are
- How the weeks differ: study, work and time
- What each route costs, and what you earn
- Qualifications and career doors
- Completion and outcomes: read the numbers carefully
- How you apply
- Which route suits which person
- Why your sixth form results matter for both routes
- Using Schoolwize to compare sixth forms
- FAQ
- Sources
What the two routes actually are
A university degree is a full-time academic course, usually three years in England, taught on campus and funded mainly through tuition fee loans and maintenance support. An apprenticeship is a job with structured training. GOV.UK says apprenticeships in England can take from 8 months to 6 years depending on the type and level, and that you must be 16 or over, living in England and not in full-time education to start.
Apprenticeships come at different levels, and this is where the comparison with university becomes meaningful. The same GOV.UK page sets out the equivalents:
| Apprenticeship level | Equivalent to |
|---|---|
| Intermediate (Level 2) | GCSE |
| Advanced (Level 3) | A level |
| Higher (Levels 4 to 7) | Foundation degree and above |
| Degree (Levels 6 and 7) | Bachelor’s or master’s degree |
So when people ask whether an apprenticeship is worth the same as a degree, the first question is which level. A Level 3 advanced apprenticeship is a different proposition from a Level 6 degree apprenticeship. The Education Hub explains that if a degree apprenticeship exists in your chosen occupation, you earn the same qualification as a full-time university student, with years of work experience on top. Aston University adds that degree apprentices are awarded the same quality of degree as traditional students, and that the courses are just as academically challenging.
How the weeks differ: study, work and time
The daily rhythm is the biggest practical difference.
At university, your timetable is set by lectures, seminars and independent study, and many students also take part-time work. As a degree apprentice, you are an employee. UCAS states that degree apprenticeships take three to six years depending on level, with about 20% of your time spent studying and 80% working. The DfE’s guide to higher and degree apprenticeships says apprentices get a contract of employment and at least 20 days’ paid holiday a year plus bank holidays, and that you will usually work a minimum of 30 hours a week.
That means fewer holidays than school or university. The same guide is clear that an apprenticeship is not the easy option: you are expected to achieve academically and at work, manage your time well, and you might need to travel or relocate to find the right opportunity. Discover Uni makes the same point: working and studying together can be hard, with expectations in both.
If you like being given a project and a deadline, working alongside experienced colleagues, and learning by doing, this rhythm may suit you. If you want time to explore a subject in depth, change direction, or live away from home in a student community, university offers more room for that.
What each route costs, and what you earn
The university cost
Prospects states that an undergraduate degree costs up to £9,790 a year in tuition fees for 2026/27, plus living expenses, and that you do not begin student loan repayments until you earn at least £25,000 a year. Fees are normally covered by a loan, so the cost arrives later as a deduction from pay rather than upfront. Still, it is debt, and it is worth understanding before you sign up for it.
The apprenticeship cost
For an apprentice, training is paid by the employer and the government, so there are no tuition fees. Prospects notes that if you are under 25, funding covers training up to Level 6 (bachelor’s degree level). It also states that from January 2026, funding for Level 7 (master’s) apprenticeships is restricted to people under 22, or under 25 with an Education, Health and Care (EHC) plan. If a master’s-level apprenticeship is part of your plan, check that rule on the official funding pages.
You are also paid. UCAS gives an average salary of around £23,000 for degree apprentices in its comparison of a traditional degree and a degree apprenticeship. Wages vary widely by employer, sector and region, so treat any single average as a guide only. The statutory minimum rates change each April, so look up the current figures on GOV.UK.
One trade-off to note: UCAS lists that degree apprentices do not qualify for student loans, and the market for places is extremely competitive.
Earnings later on
The Resolution Foundation’s report Are universities worth it? found that the median wage for graduates aged 21 to 30 was £31,500 in 2023, against £26,500 for non-graduates. It also found that the real earnings premium for young graduates fell from £6,000 to £4,000 over the decade. Graduates still earn more on average, but the gap has narrowed, and these are averages across all courses and jobs, not predictions for you. The subject and the occupation matter more than the label of the route.
Qualifications and career doors
Each route can lead to strong careers, but they open different doors.
Per Prospects, an apprenticeship may lead to an NVQ, HNC or HND, a higher apprenticeship to a foundation degree, and a degree apprenticeship to a full honours degree. A university education lets you target a broader range of careers. Apprenticeship skills are tied to a particular industry or role, and you will likely stay with the employer for a set number of years. Certain professions in healthcare, business and science require a degree.
If you have a career in mind, work backwards from it:
- Find the job on the National Careers Service or the employer’s own page and read the entry requirements.
- Check whether a degree apprenticeship exists for that occupation, and which employers offer it.
- If the job requires a specific degree (medicine, for example), plan your A-level subjects accordingly.
- If you are unsure, pick the route that keeps the most options open, usually strong A levels or equivalent qualifications.
Some employers recruit for graduate schemes in competitive fields such as investment banking and consulting, where the university route is common. Always check the specific employer’s current entry routes rather than relying on a general rule.
Completion and outcomes: read the numbers carefully
The King’s College London Policy Institute’s Are universities worth it? report states that the overall completion rate for apprenticeships is about 55%, compared with about 89% for university degrees. It also says degree apprenticeships delivered by a university match wider university completion performance. So the headline gap is largely about the mix of apprenticeships included, not a verdict on degree apprenticeships.
NCFE reports, citing DfE data, that 84% of apprentices were satisfied with their experience on completion, and that 93% of people who completed an apprenticeship in 2020/21 sustained employment, against 87.7% of working-age graduates in work. NCFE also cautions that apprenticeship statistics include both young people under 19 starting out and established professionals upskilling, so they should be read with care.
The lesson is practical: a good choice is not just choosing a route but choosing the right course or employer, and staying with it.
How you apply
Applications work differently, and the deadlines do not line up.
- University: you apply through UCAS, with a personal statement, predicted grades and references. The main deadlines are set each year, so check the UCAS site for the current cycle.
- Degree apprenticeship: Aston University states you do not apply through UCAS but directly to the employer offering the place. Employers recruit throughout the year, often from the autumn of Year 13 or earlier.
- Other apprenticeships: vacancies are advertised on the government’s Find an apprenticeship service, and you can apply to several at once.
Because apprenticeship recruitment runs alongside university applications, many students apply to both. That is a sensible approach: it keeps options open until offers and results arrive. Whichever you choose, your predicted and actual grades will matter, because both employers and universities often set entry requirements by grade and subject.
Which route suits which person
Prospects puts the decision in useful terms: you are choosing between two experiences, not whether to gain a degree, so the question is whether you prefer a theory-based academic approach or a practical work-based one.
| Question | Points towards university | Points towards an apprenticeship |
|---|---|---|
| How do you learn best? | Reading, discussion, independent study | Doing the job, learning from colleagues |
| Is your career choice clear? | Not yet, or several options | Yes, and an employer offers a route |
| How do you feel about money? | Comfortable with a loan repaid later | Want pay and no tuition debt now |
| Where do you want to live? | Open to moving for a campus | Happy to be tied to an employer’s location |
| Does the job require a degree? | Yes, for many healthcare and science roles | A degree apprenticeship exists for it |
The NCFE survey of apprentices found the main reasons for choosing the route were gaining experience alongside a qualification (74%), career progression (51%) and hands-on experience (46%). If those match your priorities, an apprenticeship deserves serious attention. If you want a broad choice of careers later, university may suit you better.
Why your sixth form results matter for both routes
Both paths start with grades. Competitive degree apprenticeships and university courses set A-level or equivalent requirements, and the subjects you take decide which doors are open. So the choice of sixth form or college at 16 is the first step in this decision, not a separate one.
When you compare sixth forms, headline averages hide what you need. A school may do well overall but be weaker in the subjects you plan to take. Look at results subject by subject and grade by grade, and look at the trend over several years, because a single strong year can be a blip. The government’s own data covers this, but it is spread across several services built for analysts. You can also see A-level results across schools in England, and, if you are aiming for the most selective universities, the Oxford and Cambridge offers table. Specialist providers can be worth a look too: Aston University Mathematics School is one example of a post-16 school with a clear subject focus. Our data sources and methodology page explains where every figure comes from.
Using Schoolwize to compare sixth forms

Schoolwize rebuilds the Department for Education’s published data into plain-English school profiles for every primary, secondary and sixth form school in England. You can see results subject by subject, benchmark each figure against the local authority and England on the same scale, and follow each measure across several years. The benchmarks and trends are our own derived analysis of official data, not figures the government hands over ready-made. The profiles also cover Ofsted inspection history, admissions demand, support for additional needs and outcomes after school.
Everything is free to browse, and you can create a Free Pass to get started. For the deepest subject-level detail, the Decision Pass is available from the pricing page: £19.99 one-off for 1 Month, £39.99 one-off for 3 Months, or £14.99 per month on the monthly plan. A few weeks of research is usually enough to compare a shortlist of sixth forms.

There is no paid ranking and no way for a school to buy better treatment, so the figures you see are the official ones, presented independently.
Our view: the decision starts before 18
We spend our days with the government’s school data, and one thing stands out: families often treat apprenticeship versus university as a choice made at 18, when the options are shaped much earlier by the subjects and grades a young person leaves school with.
England publishes some of the best school data in the world, but it sits in services built for analysts. We built Schoolwize so that a parent or a student can see how a sixth form performs in a particular subject, how that compares with the local area and with England, and whether the pattern holds across several years.
That matters here because a student who keeps both routes open, with strong grades in the right subjects, can choose the degree, the degree apprenticeship or the employer they actually want. Our aim is to make that first decision, which school or college, an informed one.
Schoolwize Blog Team
FAQ
Is a degree apprenticeship as good as a degree?
A degree apprenticeship leads to a full undergraduate or master’s degree, the same as a traditional route, according to the Education Hub. Aston University says the courses are as academically challenging and the degree is of the same quality. The difference is the experience: you are employed, working most of the week and studying the rest.
Will I have student debt if I do an apprenticeship?
Apprenticeship training is paid for by your employer and the government, so there are no tuition fees to borrow against. The DfE’s guide notes that you earn throughout, so there are no university debts. Funding rules differ by age and level, so check the current rules on GOV.UK for your situation.
What is the 42-day rule for apprenticeships?
It is the qualifying period for apprenticeship funding. Under the DfE’s funding rules for 2025 to 2026, an apprentice must be in learning for at least 42 days for funding to be earned. If an apprentice leaves before then, no funding is earned and any already paid is reclaimed. This is a rule about provider funding, not a hurdle you apply for.
Can I apply for both university and an apprenticeship?
Yes. University applications go through UCAS, while degree apprenticeships go directly to employers, so the two run side by side. Many students apply to both until offers and results arrive, which keeps choices open.
Do I need a degree for my chosen career?
It depends on the job. Prospects notes that certain professions in healthcare, business and science require a degree. Check the entry requirements for the specific role, and speak to a careers adviser, for example through the National Careers Service, before you finalise your A-level choices.
Sources
- Your A level results are in: exploring apprenticeships (Education Hub, 2025)
- Alternatives to A Levels and university (Education Hub, 2023)
- Become an apprentice: How apprenticeships work (GOV.UK)
- The complete guide to higher and degree apprenticeships (DfE)
- Degree apprenticeships (UCAS)
- Traditional degree or degree apprenticeship? (UCAS)
- Should I go to university or do an apprenticeship? (Prospects)
- Are universities worth it? (Resolution Foundation)
- Are universities worth it? (King’s College London Policy Institute)
- FAQs: Degree Apprenticeships (Aston University)
- About apprenticeships (Discover Uni)
- Apprenticeships vs university (NCFE)
- Apprenticeship funding rules 2025 to 2026 (DfE)